Model Uncertainty First, Not Afterwards

Abstract

Watson and Holmes propose ways of investigating robustness of statistical decisions by examining certain neighbourhoods around a posterior distribution. This may partly amount to ad hoc modelling of extra uncertainty. Instead of creating neighbourhoods around the posterior a posteriori, we argue that it might be more fruitful to model a layer of extra uncertainty first, in the model building process, and then allow the data to determine how big the resulting neighbourhoods ought to be. We develop and briefly illustrate a general strategy along such lines.