Statistical Science

A Public Health Controversy in 19th Century Canada

David R. Bellhouse and Christian Genest

Full-text: Open access

Abstract

From 1858 to 1860, the English naturalist and social activist Philip P. Carpenter toured North America. In April of 1859 he visited Montréal, Canada. Shocked by the sanitary conditions of the city, he wrote a paper that used statistical arguments to call for health reforms. Six years later he settled in Montréal and quickly became an active promoter of this cause. He began accumulating additional numerical evidence in support of his views.

In the aftermath of a cholera scare in 1866, Carpenter became the driving force behind the creation of the Montreal Sanitary Association. That same year he published a second, more detailed article that took advantage of the 1861 census data to analyze mortality rates in Montréal. He made further statistical investigations in 1869.

Unfortunately, Carpenter did not understand some of the subtleties associated with the analysis of vital statistics. An obscure bookkeeper, Andrew A. Watt, made a scathing public attack on both Carpenter’s data and his interpretation thereof. In a series of newspaper articles, Watt scrutinized systematically all of Carpenter’s writings, showing his faults and correcting them wherever he could.

Although Watt’s arguments were correct, the public was slow to understand them. The controversy continued through 1870. When the nature of Watt’s criticisms finally became better understood and Carpenter persisted with statistical arguments, the latter lost credibility and was abandoned by his own association.

Article information

Source
Statist. Sci., Volume 20, Number 2 (2005), 178-192.

Dates
First available in Project Euclid: 14 July 2005

Permanent link to this document
https://projecteuclid.org/euclid.ss/1121347639

Digital Object Identifier
doi:10.1214/088342305000000052

Mathematical Reviews number (MathSciNet)
MR2183448

Zentralblatt MATH identifier
1188.01009

Keywords
Andrew A. Watt Philip P. Carpenter crude death rate Montreal Sanitary Association mortality comparisons public health sanitation standardized mortality ratio statistical controversies

Citation

Bellhouse, David R.; Genest, Christian. A Public Health Controversy in 19th Century Canada. Statist. Sci. 20 (2005), no. 2, 178--192. doi:10.1214/088342305000000052. https://projecteuclid.org/euclid.ss/1121347639


Export citation

References

  • Carpenter, J. E. (1881). The Life and Work of Mary Carpenter, 2nd ed. Macmillan, London.
  • Carpenter, M. (1851). Reformatory Schools for the Children of the Perishing and Dangerous Classes and for Juvenile Offenders. C. Gilpin, London.
  • Carpenter, M. (1853). Juvenile Delinquents, Their Condition and Treatment. W. & F. G. Cash, London.
  • Carpenter, M. (1857). On the importance of statistics to the reformatory movement, with returns from female reformatories, and remarks on them. J. Statistical Society of London 20 33--40.
  • Carpenter, M. (1864). Our Convicts. Longman, Green, Longman, Roberts & Green, London.
  • Carpenter, P. P. (1859). On the relative value of human life in different parts of Canada. Canadian Naturalist and Geologist 6 173--186.
  • Carpenter, P. P. (1866). On the vital statistics of Montreal. The Canadian Naturalist 3 134--156.
  • Carpenter, P. P. (1869). On some of the causes of the excess mortality of young children in the city of Montreal. The Canadian Naturalist 6 188--206.
  • Carpenter, R. L. (1842). Memoirs of the Life of the Reverend Lant Carpenter, L.L.D. Philp and Evans, Bristol, England.
  • Carpenter, R. L. (1880). Memoirs of the Life and Work of Philip Pearsall Carpenter. C. Kegan Paul and Co., London.
  • Chadwick, E. (1844). On the best modes of representing accurately, by statistical returns, the duration of life, and the pressure and progress of the causes of mortality amongst different classes of the community, and amongst the populations of different districts and countries. J. Statistical Society of London 7 1--40.
  • Coan, E. V. (1969). A bibliography of the biological writings of Philip Pearsall Carpenter. The Veliger 12 222--225.
  • Cullen, M. J. (1975). The Statistical Movement in Early Victorian Britain: The Foundations of Empirical Social Research. Barnes and Noble, New York.
  • Dall, W. H. (1877). Dr. Philip Pearsall Carpenter. American Naturalist 11 504--505.
  • Farr, W. (1837). Vital statistics, or the statistics of health, sickness, diseases, and death. In A Statistical Account of the British Empire: Exhibiting its Extent, Physical Capacities, Population, Industry, and Civil and Religious Institutions (J. R. MacCulloch, ed.) 567--601. C. Knight, London. (Reprinted 1974 in Mortality in Mid-19th Century Britain, Gregg, Farnborough.)
  • Farr, W. (1865). On infant mortality, and on alleged inaccuracies of the census. J. Statistical Society of London 28 125--149.
  • Farr, W. (1885). Vital Statistics: A Memorial Volume of Selections from the Reports and Writings of William Farr, M.D., D.C.L., C.B., F.R.S.N. (N. A. Humphreys, ed.). Sanitary Institute of London, London. (Reprinted 1975 by Scarecrow Press, Metuchen, NJ.)
  • Fenwick, G. E. (1861). The medical statistics of the city of Montreal. The British American Journal 2 390--394, 439--442, 489--493, 527--531.
  • Fox, J. J. (1859). On the vital statistics of the Society of Friends. J. Statistical Society of London 22 208--231.
  • Glasgow and Clydesdale Statistical Society (1836). Constitution and Regulations of the Glasgow and Clydesdale Statistical Society. Bell and Bain, Glasgow, Scotland.
  • Hall, A. (1847). Observations on the mortality of the city of Montreal, for the year 1846. The British American Journal of Medical and Physical Science 3 141--144.
  • Hall, A. (1861a). The mortality of the city of Montreal during the year 1860. The British American Journal 2 79--81.
  • Hall, A. (1861b). The mortality of Montreal. The British American Journal 2 130--132.
  • Jones, D. (1844). On the Value of Annuities and Reversionary Payments. Baldwin, London.
  • Jopling, R. T. (1851). Sanitary statistics of the metropolis. J. Statistical Society of London 14 337--343.
  • Langton, J. (1863--1864). The census of 1861. Transactions of the Literary and Historical Society of Quebec 2 103--124.
  • Montreal Sanitary Association (1867). First Annual Report of the Montreal Sanitary Association, Presented to a Public Meeting of the Members and Friends, Held in the Mechanics' Hall, March 28, 1867, Wm. Workman, Esq., President, in the Chair. Gazette Printing House, Montréal (Québec), Canada.
  • Montreal Sanitary Association (1871). Fifth Annual Report of the Montreal Sanitary Association with the Proceedings at the Annual Meeting, Held at the Natural History Hall, April 13th, 1871 and an Account of the Proceedings which Led to the Dissolution of the Society. Gazette Printing House, Montréal (Québec), Canada.
  • Sheet-Pyenson, S. (1996). John William Dawson: Faith, Hope and Science. McGill--Queen's University Press, Montréal (Québec) and Kingston (Ontario), Canada.
  • Stephen, L. and Lee, S. (1921--1922). The Dictionary of National Biography. Oxford University Press, London.
  • Taché, J.-C. (1866). Memorial to the Board of Registration and Statistics. Sessional Papers (No. 5), Vol. 2, Fifth Session of the Eighth Parliament of the Province of Canada, Session 1866. Hunter, Rose and Company, Ottawa (Ontario), Canada.
  • Watt, A. A. (1869). Notes on the Principles of Population: Montreal Compared with London, Glasgow, and Manchester, With an Examination of the Vital Statistics by Philip P. Carpenter, B.A., Ph.D., one of the Honorary Secretaries of the Montreal Sanitary Association. Murray and Company, Montréal (Québec), Canada.
  • Watt, A. A. (1870--1871). Notes on the principles of population: Montreal compared with London, Glasgow, and Manchester. Canada Medical Journal and Monthly Record of Medical and Surgical Science 6 248--261, 307--326.