Electronic Journal of Statistics

Further statistical analysis of circle fitting

Ali Al-Sharadqah

Full-text: Open access

Abstract

This study is devoted to comparing the most popular circle fits (the geometric fit, Pratt’s, Taubin’s, Kåsa’s) and the most recently developed algebraic circle fits: hyperaccurate fit and HyperLS fit. Even though hyperaccurate fit has zero essential bias and HyperLS fit is unbiased up to order $\sigma^{4}$, the geometric fit still outperforms them in some circumstances. Since the first-order leading term of the MSE for all fits are equal, we go one step further and derive all terms of order $\sigma^{4}$, which come from essential bias, as well as all terms of order $\sigma^{4}/n$, which come from two sources: the variance and the outer product of the essential bias and the nonessential bias.

Our analysis shows that when data are distributed along a short circular arc, the covariance part is the dominant part of the second-order term in the MSE. Accordingly, the geometric fit outperforms all existing methods. However, for a long circular arc, the bias becomes the most dominant part of the second-order term, and as such, hyperaccurate fit and HyperLS fit outperform the geometric fit. We finally propose a ‘bias correction’ version of the geometric fit, which in turn, outperforms all existing methods. The new method has two features. Its variance is the smallest and has zero bias up to order $\sigma^{4}$. Our numerical tests confirm the superiority of the proposed fit over the existing fits.

Article information

Source
Electron. J. Statist., Volume 8, Number 2 (2014), 2741-2778.

Dates
First available in Project Euclid: 1 January 2015

Permanent link to this document
https://projecteuclid.org/euclid.ejs/1420071974

Digital Object Identifier
doi:10.1214/14-EJS971

Mathematical Reviews number (MathSciNet)
MR3296142

Zentralblatt MATH identifier
1315.68214

Subjects
Primary: 68T10: Pattern recognition, speech recognition {For cluster analysis, see 62H30} 68K45
Secondary: 68K40 62P30: Applications in engineering and industry

Keywords
Circle fitting computer vision small-noise model algebraic fit geometric fit mean squared error bias variance

Citation

Al-Sharadqah, Ali. Further statistical analysis of circle fitting. Electron. J. Statist. 8 (2014), no. 2, 2741--2778. doi:10.1214/14-EJS971. https://projecteuclid.org/euclid.ejs/1420071974


Export citation

References

  • [1] Al-Sharadqah, A. and Chernov, N. (2009). Error analysis for circle fitting algorithms., Electronic Journal of Statistics. 3 886–911.
  • [2] Al-Sharadqah, A. and Chernov, N. (2011). Statistical analysis of curve fitting methods in errors-in-variables models., Theor. Probability and Math. Statist. 84 4–17
  • [3] Al-Sharadqah, A. and Chernov, N. (2012). A doubly optimal ellipse fit., Computational Statistics and Data Analysis 56 2771–2781.
  • [4] Al-Sharadqah, A. and Chernov, N. and Kanatani, K. and Sugaya, Y. (2012). Renormalization returns: Hyper-renormalization and its applications. In, European Conference on Computer Vision (ECCV 2012), 3, 385–398, Firenze, Italy, October 7–13.
  • [5] Anderson, T. W. (1976). Estimation of linear functional relationships: Approximate distributions and connections with simultaneous equations in econometric., J. R. Statist. Soc. B. 38 1–36.
  • [6] Anderson, T. W. and Sawa, T. (1982). Exact and approximate distributions of the maximum likelihood estimator of a slope coefficient., J. R. Statist. Soc. B. 44 52–62.
  • [7] Atieg, A. and Watson, G. A. (2004). Fitting circular arcs by orthogonal distance regression., Appl. Numer. Anal. Comput. Math. 1 66–76.
  • [8] Chan, N. N. (1965). On circular functional relationships., J. R. Statist. Soc. B. 27 45–56.
  • [9] Chan, Y. T. and Thomas, S. M. (1995). Cramer-Rao lower bounds for estimation of a circular arc center and its radius., Graph. Models Image Proc. 57 527–532.
  • [10] Chernov, N. (2010). Circular and linear regression: Fitting circles and lines by least squares, volume 117., Chapman & Hall/CRC, Boca Raton.
  • [11] Chernov, N. and Lesort, C. (2004). Statistical efficiency of curve fitting algorithms., Comp. Stat. Data Anal. 47 713–728.
  • [12] Chernov, N. and Lesort, C. (2005). Least squares fitting of circles., J. Math. Imag. Vision 23 239–251.
  • [13] Chernov, N. and Sapirstein, P. (2008). Fitting circles to data with correlated noise., Comput. Statist. Data Anal. 52 5328–5337.
  • [14] Cooke, T. (2010). A fast automatic ellipse detector., Digital Image Computing: Techniques and Applications (DICTA).
  • [15] Delogne, P. (1972). Computer optimization of Deschamps’ method and error cancellation in reflectometry., Proc. IMEKO-Symp. Microwave Measurement (Budapest), 117–123.
  • [16] Fuller, W. A. (1987). Measurement Error Models., Wiley & Son, New York.
  • [17] Joseph, S. H. (1994). Unbiased least-squares fitting of circular arcs., Graph. Mod. Image Process 56 424–432.
  • [18] Kadane, J. B. (1970). Testing overidentifying restrictions when the disturbances are small., J. Amer. Statist. Assoc. 65 182–185.
  • [19] Kanatani, K. (1998). Cramer-Rao lower bounds for curve fitting., Graph. Mod. Image Process 60 93–99.
  • [20] Kanatani, K. (2004). For geometric inference from images: What kind of statistical model is necessary?, Syst. Comp. Japan 35 1–9.
  • [21] Kanatani, K. (2005). Optimality of maximum likelihood estimation for geometric fitting and the KCR lower bound., Memoirs Fac. Engin. Okayama Univ. 39 63–70.
  • [22] Kanatani, K. (2008). Statistical optimization for geometric fitting: Theoretical accuracy bound and high order error analysis., Int. J. Computer Vision 80 167–188.
  • [23] Kanatani, K. and Rangarajan, P. (2009). Improved algebraic methods for circle fitting., Electr. J. Statist. 3 1075–1082.
  • [24] Kåsa, I. (1976). A curve fitting procedure and its error analysis., IEEE Trans. Inst. Meas. 25 8–14.
  • [25] Kilambi, S. and Tipton, S. (2011). Development of a laser scan inspection tool for coiled tubing., SPE/ICoTA Coiled Tubing & Well Intervention Conference and Exhibition.
  • [26] Landau, U. M. (1987). Estimation of a circular arc center and its radius., CVGIP: Image Understanding 38 317–326.
  • [27] Pratt, V. (1987). Direct least-squares fitting of algebraic surfaces., Computer Graphics 21 145–152.
  • [28] Sarkar, B., Singh, L. K. and Sarkar, D. (2003). Approximation of digital curves with line segments and circular arcs using genetic algorithms., Pattern Recogn. Letters 24 2585–2595.
  • [29] Späth, H. (1996). Least-squares fitting by circles., Computing 57 179–185.
  • [30] Strandlie, A., Wroldsen,J., Frühwirth, R. and Lillekjendlie, B. (2000). Particle tracks fitted on the Riemann sphere., Computer Physics Commun. 131 95–108.
  • [31] Taubin, G. (1991). Estimation of planar curves, surfaces and nonplanar space curves defined by implicit equations, with applications to edge and range image segmentation., IEEE Trans. Pattern Analysis Machine Intelligence 13 1115–1138.
  • [32] Teixidó, M. (2012). Two-dimensional radial laser scanning for circular marker detection and external mobile robot tracking., Sensors 12 16482–16497.
  • [33] Wang, T., Li, B. and Wu, T. (2010). Study on pre-correction method for led chip declination in sorting system., International Conference on Mechatronics and Automation 1110–1114.
  • [34] Wu, T. (2010). Study on auto-path planning according to grade priority for sorting dies., International Conference on Machine Learning and Cybernetics (ICMLC) 3.
  • [35] Yin, S. J. and Wang, S. G. (2004). Estimating the parameters of a circle by heteroscedastic regression models., J. Statist. Planning Infer. 124 439–451.
  • [36] Zelniker, E. and Clarkson, V. (2006). Maximum-likelihood estimation of circle parameters via convolution., IEEE Trans. Image Proc. 15 865–876.
  • [37] Zelniker, E. and Clarkson, V. (2006). A statistical analysis of the Delogne-Kåsa method for fitting circles., Digital Signal Proc. 16 498–552.
  • [38] Zhang, S., Xie, L. and Adams, M. D. (2006). Feature extraction for outdoor mobile robot navigation based on a modified Gauss Newton optimization approach., Robotics Autonom. Syst. 54 277–287.
  • [39] Zhao, Y. and Xiong, C. (2011). Prediction-based geometric feature extraction for 2nd laser scanner., Robotics and Autonomous Systems 59(6) 402–409.